top of page

Be Notified of New Research Summaries -

It's Free!

Are Economic Outcomes Improving for American Indians?

Writer: Greg Thorson
Greg Thorson
4 minutes ago
7 min read

Akee and Simeonova (forthcoming) document important gains on American Indian reservations: child poverty fell from 55% to 43% between 1990 and 2021, and the share of adults with a college degree tripled, from 3% to 9%, between 1990 and 2020. Over the same period, however, the national share of college graduates rose to 34%, so the gap with the rest of the country widened. Reviewing decades of research and analyzing Census Bureau and other federal data, the authors also show that measured outcomes depend on who is counted. Among adults ages 25–54, 25% of people who identify as American Indian alone or with another race hold a college degree, compared with 17% of those who identify as American Indian alone.


Why This Article Was Selected for The Policy Scientist

Federal policies of forced removal, land cessions, and compulsory boarding schools imposed severe and lasting economic costs on many tribal nations. Since the 1970s, federal policy has shifted toward tribal self-determination, giving tribes greater control over their own governance and economic development. How economic conditions have changed under that arrangement, and how much they vary across tribes and places, remains a question of continuing relevance as courts, Congress, and federal statistical agencies address child welfare jurisdiction, tribal recognition, and how Native Americans are counted. Forthcoming in the Journal of Economic Literature, a leading journal of the American Economic Association, this review by authors who have published extensively in the field synthesizes a rapidly growing literature and shows how measurement choices shape what researchers conclude. Although primarily descriptive, it provides a strong foundation for future causal research.


Full Citation and Link to Article

Akee, R., & Simeonova, E. (forthcoming). Beyond the conventional narrative: Economic heterogeneity and human capital among American Indians. Journal of Economic Literature.


Central Research Question

How have American Indians fared economically since federal policy shifted toward tribal self-determination, and how much do the answers depend on whether people are counted by race, by multiracial identity, or by tribal citizenship? The study reviews research on education, employment, earnings, health, and intergenerational mobility, and considers how geography, natural resources, and federal policy have contributed to very different circumstances across tribal nations.


The authors note that public perceptions of American Indians often rest on two familiar images, persistent poverty or casino wealth, and that the evidence points to considerably more variation than either suggests. The definitional question is equally important. Counting people who also identify with another race more than doubles the American Indian population and changes its composition, while tribal citizenship is a distinct legal status that determines eligibility for many federal programs. Which group researchers study can shape what they find.


Previous Literature

A substantial body of economic research links historical federal policies to persistent differences in economic outcomes. Dippel (2014) and Feir et al. (2024a) connect lasting economic disadvantage to relocation onto reservations and the loss of land and resources. Feir et al. (2024b) find that the near-extinction of the bison, on which many tribes depended, was followed by higher infant mortality and lower adult height. Evidence on boarding schools is more mixed. Feir (2016) and Gregg (2018) find that attendance raised later education and employment, but Feir (2016) also documents weakened connections to Indigenous communities and languages, and Jones (2024) finds a negative intergenerational association in education among First Nations families in Canada.


A second body of research examines the period of greater tribal self-governance, much of it focused on tribal gaming. Evans and Topoleski (2002) found that tribes opening casinos experienced declines in poverty and increases in household income. Following families in one tribe over time, Akee et al. (2010) showed that casino-funded cash transfers did not reduce parents' employment and were associated with the largest educational gains among children from households initially in poverty. At the same time, Chetty et al. (2024) find that Native Americans have the lowest intergenerational income mobility of the groups they study, and Liebler et al. (2016) show that many people change whether they identify as American Indian from one census to the next. The present study brings these literatures together and shows how measurement choices shape their conclusions.


Data

The study draws primarily on Census Bureau and other federal data. Its main comparisons use the 2015–2024 American Community Survey, which includes roughly 412,000 to 509,000 American Indian and Alaska Native respondents ages 15–64 and more than 13 million non-Hispanic white respondents. The authors also use decennial census counts from 1990 to 2020, wage data from 1960 onward, the 2020 Post-Enumeration Survey, University of California enrollment records, and the 2023–2024 California Health Interview Survey, one of the few surveys that asks about both race and tribal enrollment.


Most national surveys include too few American Indian respondents for detailed analysis. The 2023 Current Population Survey includes 2,624 people who identify as American Indian alone; the 2022 National Health Interview Survey includes 372. The Survey of Consumer Finances includes too few to report, which severely limits research on wealth. The authors identify restricted administrative data in Federal Statistical Research Data Centers as a promising resource for future work.


Methods

The study synthesizes economic research on American Indian education, labor markets, health, and mobility, giving particular weight to studies that follow the same people over time. Such longitudinal studies, including recent work on tribal casinos, can separate a policy's effects from changes in who lives on reservations or who identifies as American Indian, which repeated cross-sectional surveys cannot easily do.


The authors' own analyses compare outcomes across racial definitions, tribal enrollment status, and residence on or off reservation lands. They also estimate how much more college graduates earn, comparing American Indian and white adults ages 25–54 after accounting for age, experience, family size, young children, and state. Because public data do not identify reservation residence directly, they use geographic areas containing tribal homelands as an approximation. As the authors note, these estimates describe associations rather than causal effects.


Findings/Size Effects

The principal finding is that measured outcomes for American Indians depend substantially on who is counted. Among adults ages 25–54, 25.4% of people identifying as American Indian alone or in combination with another race hold a college degree, compared with 17.0% of those identifying as American Indian alone. Nationally, child poverty is 3 to 6 percentage points lower for the broader group. In California, tribally enrolled American Indians are older than those not enrolled (average age 53 versus 47), more likely to live in rural areas (83% versus 47%), and more than twice as likely to report heart disease (15% versus 6%). The number of people identifying as American Indian alone or in combination rose 120% between 1990 and 2000, compared with 21% for the corresponding Black population, an increase the authors attribute mainly to changes in self-identification rather than births.


Differences relative to non-Hispanic whites persist on several measures. Over 2015–2024, American Indians and Alaska Natives ages 15–64 had average personal income of $45,851, 31% below the $66,767 of non-Hispanic whites. Their employment rate was 65%, compared with 74%. Among men, the median wage gap with whites has remained at roughly $20,000 (in 2020 dollars) since the 1970s. Child poverty among American Indians alone fell from 38% in 1990 to 30% in 2021 nationally, and from 55% to 43% on reservations, although these remain among the highest rates in the country. Measurement problems also affect official statistics: on-reservation housing was undercounted by about 7% in the 2020 Census, and only 59.0% of people who identified as American Indian alone, and 39.8% of those who identified in combination with another race, had that race recorded on their death certificates.


On reservations, the share of adults with a college degree tripled from 3% in 1990 to 9% in 2020. Nationally, it rose from 20% to 34%, so the gap widened from 17 to 25 percentage points. A college degree is associated with wages about 41% higher, and American Indians earn roughly 19–20% less than comparable white workers. Nationally, the earnings premium for a degree is somewhat smaller for American Indians. In areas containing tribal homelands, however, it is larger for American Indians than for white adults, a result the authors describe as novel. After the University of California began offering free tuition to California residents enrolled in federally recognized tribes in 2021, American Indian enrollment rates rose by more than 40% in the first year, although the program has not yet been formally evaluated.


Among the policies reviewed, tribal gaming has the most extensive causal evidence. The industry generated more than $40 billion in revenue in 2022. Casino openings raised the income rank of American Indians living on reservations by almost 2 percentage points, and recent linked data show average wage gains of about $2,000 for American Indian workers. In one tribe, casino-funded cash transfers of about $4,000 per year did not reduce parents' employment and raised educational attainment among children from households initially in poverty. Because much of this evidence comes from particular tribes and settings, its applicability to tribes with different resources and locations is less certain.


Conclusion

The evidence reviewed indicates that economic conditions for American Indians have improved on many measures over the past five decades, with some of the clearest gains associated with tribal gaming and greater tribal control over economic development. The size of these gains varies considerably across tribes and places, and differences with the overall population persist on several measures: American Indian and Alaska Native life expectancy is 70.1 years, 7.3 years below the overall U.S. figure. Conclusions about these differences, and about the effects of particular policies, can change substantially depending on how people are identified and where they live.


The authors offer three guidelines for future research: use consistent racial definitions over time and justify the choice between single-race and multiracial categories; distinguish tribal citizens from others who identify as American Indian; and account for whether people live on or near tribal lands, where many tribal programs are available. Many programs have not yet been rigorously evaluated, including tuition-free college programs, Tribal Head Start, tribal colleges and universities, Native language revitalization, and the Indian Health Service, and the authors recommend that such research be conducted in collaboration with American Indian communities. Research across a broader range of tribal nations would show how widely existing findings apply.

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
Screenshot of Greg Thorson
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn


The Policy Scientist

Offering Concise Summaries*
of the
Most Recent, Impactful 
Public Policy Research

*Summaries Powered by ChatGPT

bottom of page